Watch Winder vs Manual Winding: Which is Better?

Watch winding is an essential aspect of owning a timepiece that isn't battery-powered. The two main methods of winding are through the use of a watch winder machine or manually winding the watch by hand. While some people see a watch winder as a luxury item, others prefer the more traditional and hands-on approach of manual winding.

The question arises, which method is better? To truly answer this question, we need to dive into the pros and cons of each method, as well as consider niche considerations for certain types of watches.

As someone who has owned both automatic and manual watches, I believe it's important to understand all aspects of watch winding before deciding which method is best for you. So let's take a closer look at these two methods.

Shop Watch Winders at

Watch Winder: Pros and Cons

The Convenience of Watch Winders

If you are anything like me, the thought of manually winding a watch every day makes your head spin. With a watch winder, you can avoid the hassle of remembering to wind your watch regularly.

A watch winder is an automatic device that rotates a watch in order to keep it wound and ready to wear at all times. It's like having your own personal servant who ensures that your timepiece is always up and running, no matter how busy or forgetful you are.

Consistency is Key

One of the most significant advantages of using a watch winder is that it provides consistency in keeping watches wound. Consistency in winding is essential for watches with complex movements such as perpetual calendars or moon phases.

Keeping these types of watches wound can be a daunting task for even the most dedicated horologist. Watch winders provide consistency in keeping these timepieces ticking smoothly as they work through their various complications.

The Downside to Watch Winders

However, while there are several benefits to using a watch winder, there are some potential drawbacks as well. For one, they come at a cost that may be too high for some collectors on a budget. Additionally, some modern luxury watches have movements specifically designed not to operate continuously - meaning that they should not be left running 24/7 on an automatic winder as it could cause damage over time.

Furthermore, certain types of watches such as vintage pieces require special care when being wound - something which cannot be provided by an automated device like a watch winder. Similarly, if a specific movement requires manual winding because it has been left idle too long or has stopped working completely, then forcing it onto an automatic device could cause more harm than good.

While there may be a certain convenience to using watch winders, one should always be cautious when relying too heavily on them. In some cases, manual winding may still be the better option for maintaining the longevity and functionality of your timepiece.

Manual Winding: Pros and Cons

Controlling the Process: A Sense of Mastery

One of the biggest perks of manual winding is the sense of control it provides. You get to decide how much winding your watch needs, and do it yourself. This creates a feeling of mastery over your timepiece that simply cannot be replicated by a watch winder.

With every turn of the crown, you are physically engaging with your watch, feeling its mechanisms click into place beneath your fingertips. It's an intimate experience that can't quite be put into words.

A Deeper Connection to Your Watch: An Emotional Bond

In addition to this sense of control, there is also a deep emotional connection that develops between a wearer and their manually-wound timepiece. The act of winding becomes a routine, something done every day at the same time. Over time, this ritual becomes ingrained in our daily lives, acting as both a reminder to stay present and an emotional anchor that keeps us grounded throughout our busy lives.

The Drawbacks: Time-Consuming and Risky Business

As with anything in life, manual winding comes with its own set of drawbacks. For one thing, it can be incredibly time-consuming - if you're someone who wears multiple watches on rotation, for example, you'll find yourself spending a significant amount of each day just winding them up! Additionally, there's always the risk of over-winding or under-winding your watch - something that can cause significant damage over time if left unchecked.

All things considered though - despite these potential downsides - I firmly believe that manual winding is still the best way to care for your beloved timepieces. There's just something so satisfying about physically engaging with them on a daily basis; it's an experience that no amount of convenience or automation can truly replicate!

Niche Considerations

The Difference Between Automatic and Mechanical Movements

One of the most important considerations when it comes to deciding whether a watch winder or manual winding is more appropriate is the type of movement in the watch. There are two main types of movements: automatic and mechanical.

Automatic watches use an internal rotor that spins as you move, which then winds the watch. These watches are great for people who wear their watches regularly, as they will stay wound on their own.

However, if you have multiple automatic watches and don't wear them all every day, a watch winder may be necessary. On the other hand, mechanical movements must be manually wound in order to keep running.

If you have a mechanical watch that you only wear occasionally, then manual winding might be the better option for you. This will ensure that the gears in the movement remain lubricated and will help prevent damage to your watch.

Shop Watch Winders at

Vintage vs Modern Watches

Another important consideration when it comes to choosing between a watch winder or manual winding is whether you have a vintage or modern watch. Vintage watches often require more maintenance and care than modern watches.

For this reason, it might be best to avoid using a watch winder with vintage timepieces. The constant motion of a winder can damage parts within an older movement that cannot be replaced.

Modern watches are often made with more durable materials and offer better protection against external forces such as shock or water damage. In these cases, using a high-quality automatic winding machine could actually prolong your timepiece's lifespan.

Complicated Watches

If you own complicated watches such as chronographs or repeaters, then manual winding may be your best bet.There's no denying that these kinds of timepieces require more maintenance than simpler ones. A lot can go wrong with complicated movements when left unattended for long periods of time. If you leave a complex watch unattended in a winder, the mechanisms inside the watch will eventually wear out and break down.

This can be an expensive fix, so it's best to hand-wind them regularly. There is no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to deciding between a watch winder or manual winding.

It truly depends on your circumstances and personal preferences. However, by taking into account these niche considerations such as the type of movement in your watch, whether you have a vintage or modern timepiece and whether it's complicated or not – you can make an informed decision that will preserve your precious timepiece for years to come.

Rarely Known Details

The Importance of Winding Frequency

Did you know that different types of watches require different winding frequencies? It's true! For instance, an automatic watch typically needs to be worn every day or wound every two weeks to maintain proper timekeeping.

On the other hand, a manual watch only needs to be wound once per day. And if you have a quartz watch, it doesn't need to be wound at all!

Over-Winding is a Myth

Have you ever been told that over-winding your watch can cause damage? It's time to dispel that myth once and for all!

In reality, most mechanical watches have mechanisms in place that prevent over-winding. So feel free to wind your manual watch until it reaches its maximum power reserve - it won't cause any harm.

Winders Can Be Bad for Some Watches

While watch winders can be convenient for those who own multiple automatic or self-winding watches, they can actually be harmful for certain types of watches. For example, vintage watches or those made with delicate materials may not fare well in a constantly moving environment like a watch winder. Plus, some manufacturers recommend against using winders altogether.


The debate between watch winder vs manual winding is complex and depends on many factors unique to each individual's collection of timepieces. While both methods have their pros and cons, ultimately the decision comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of each watch in question.

One thing is certain - regardless of whether you choose to use a watch winder or manually wind your timepieces each day, proper care and maintenance are key in ensuring their longevity and accuracy. So take good care of your watches and enjoy them for years to come!

Visa Mastercard American Express PayPal Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Klarna Maestro Shop Pay SOFORT
Follow Us